Zimbio, in photo: Justin Bieber, Mariah Yeater
5. Justin Bieber was rumored to be with Mariah Yeater
October 2010 - October 2010

In November, 2011, Mariah Yeater filed a suit alleging that Justin Bieber fathered her 3-month-old baby. Bieber's camp immediately denied the claims that they had a one-time tryst backstage during a show.